August 9, 2022


Let'S Talk Law

Substantial Court docket sanctions Virgin Active restructuring options


This landmark judgment affirms the usefulness of restructuring strategies as a holistic restructuring answer to handle the two fiscal and operational liabilities, these types of as landlord liabilities.

Next this decision, we count on battling firms to look for to place in spot restructuring ideas in growing number.

What is a restructuring approach?

A restructuring program is a new restructuring tool introduced into Part 26A of the Companies Act 2006 in June 2020 by the Company Insolvency and Governance Act 2020. It constitutes an “arrangement” or “compromise” in between the business and its stakeholders and will consequence in a reduction or reshaping of the liabilities owed to people stakeholders.

The process for a restructuring strategy is quite comparable to the perfectly-established “plan of arrangement” regime, with stakeholders break up into courses in respect of each their treatment method less than the proposal and for voting needs. However, contrary to a plan of arrangement, a restructuring approach enables for dissenting lessons of stakeholders to be sure in specific instances. This is known as “cross-course cram down”.


The Virgin Active team is a properly-set up operator of wellbeing golf equipment. Virgin Active’s finances suffered drastically as a outcome of Covid-19 and the limitations imposed on wellbeing clubs and gyms. In a rescue effort, Virgin Active sought to restructure the monetary and operational liabilities of its European and Asia-Pacific organizations.

The restructuring designs

To put into practice the restructuring, 3 businesses in just the Virgin Active team released restructuring options (the VARPs). The VARPs sought to restructure the plan companies’ liabilities owed to 7 courses of lenders, summarised as follows:

  • Secured collectors
  • Existing landlords, split into classes A to F and
  • Typical house collectors, this kind of as people to whom ensure liabilities had been owed.

In a very first for restructuring programs, the approach companies sought to use this regime to restructure their house liabilities. In a similar way to that observed in a regular company voluntary arrangement, the VARPs categorised their operational liabilities into courses, based mostly mostly on the profitability of the suitable lease, with every course then matter to various treatment. The goal of this was to restructure the companies’ leasehold portfolio into one thing additional sustainable. This operational restructuring sat alongside a monetary restructuring which would see new funds furnished by the shareholders and commitments and compromises provided by the secured lenders. Jointly this would supply for a holistic restructuring of the approach companies’ liabilities.

Sanction and cross-course cram down 

The VARPs had been strongly objected to by an advert hoc team of landlords who elevated arguments against the VARPs at both of those the convening listening to and the sanction listening to.

As the program firms unsuccessful to obtain votes in favour from 75{48802e074c5f965745cb161aba42404553935aa8d7cf9aecda1745fcd7825477} in benefit of creditors in the vast majority of creditor lessons, it was essential for the prepare providers to ask the courtroom to work out its discretion to sanction the VARPs in any function, employing the cross-course cram down mechanism. 

Below area 901G of the Organizations Act, a restructuring plan can still be sanctioned by the court docket wherever one particular or extra classes do not vote in favour of the prepare, provided that the following disorders are satisfied:

  • none of the dissenting course would be any even worse off than they would be in party of the pertinent substitute – in this case, administration and
  • the strategy had been permitted by at minimum 1 class of collectors who would have had a authentic financial fascination in the pertinent different.

Even though the bulk of creditor classes voted from the VARPs, a essential reality in this circumstance was that the secured loan providers and the program companies’ “Course A” landlords voted overwhelmingly in favour. The evidence prior to the court docket was that on an administration the value would “split” in the secured financial debt these kinds of that none of the landlords, or other unsecured lenders, would obtain any return, help save for in regard of the prescribed aspect. The return to all lenders below the VARPs was thus increased than they would acquire on an administration.

The choose, Mr Justice Snowden, was glad on the proof in advance of the court docket that none of the customers of any of the dissenting lessons would be any even worse off underneath the VARPs than in that pertinent different. It was not disputed that the VARPs experienced been accepted by at the very least one particular class of lenders who would have had a real financial interest in the applicable alternate provided the help of the secured creditors.

In considering the court’s standard discretion to sanction the VARPs, Mr Justice Snowden considered at duration the cure of “in the money” versus “out of the cash” collectors. This delivers beneficial steering on the value of the differing passions of these lenders who are “in the dollars”, such as the secured loan companies in this case, as in comparison with these collectors who are “out of the dollars”, this kind of as the landlords and other unsecured creditors listed here, when contemplating the distribution of the positive aspects of the restructuring.

Dismissing the objections of the landlords, Mr Justice Snowden determined that the court docket really should workout its discretion to sanction the VARPs utilising the cross-class cram down mechanism.

What following?

The restructuring approach regime is still quite new but we now have a handful of cases which exhibit it to be a useful and versatile software. The sanction of the VARPs illustrates that restructuring strategies have vast-ranging use, such as in the restructure of lease liabilities. Whilst the cases we have observed to-day have associated significant-scale operations, this situation illustrates that restructuring options can supply a holistic alternative for corporations searching to handle their operational as well as their economical liabilities, and we foresee that they will start to be employed throughout the industry to address a range of cases.

This most up-to-date final decision is, even so, a further more blow for landlords who also confronted defeat in the problem to the New Glimpse enterprise voluntary arrangement (CVA). The results of the companies in every single of the New Glance and Virgin Lively scenarios highlights that, for now at minimum, CVAs and restructuring designs each continue to be practical instruments for providers looking for to restructure their liabilities.